Disney's Princess Tiana: A Gift Or A Curse
Better Than Nothing?
 

princesstiana1.jpgWhen Disney announced last year that an feature-length animated with a black heroine was in the works, I was beyond thrilled. Growing up, I was a major Disney buff — like most children of the 80s, I presume — and although I still have a great amount of affection for the classics, as I grew older my disappointment in the company's apparent lack of interest in including black characters in its animated films began to overshadow that childhood love. But now they're making a black, animated Disney film! My future daughters will have their own animated heroine to look up to! Unfortunately, based on information from people in the know, I might have gotten excited too soon. Disney, a company with a racially-murky past that won't stay in the vault no matter how hard execs try to keep it hidden, appears to be having quite a few problems coming up with a storyline that isn't offensive. Fancy that.

In Disney's first version of the film, set in 1920s New Orleans, the heroine was a subservient black chambermaid named Maddy who works for a white debutante until she's saved by a voodoo priestess/fairy godmother who helps her get with a white prince. That storyline was scrapped… for so many reasons. Now, the movie is still set in New Orleans but revolves around Princess Tiana, voiced by Anika Noni Rose, and her love interest is apparently a prince (?) of Middle Eastern descent named Naveen.

I'm not sure why this has been (and continues to be) so hard for Disney. I'm also not sure why there seems to be a conscious effort to make sure Princess Tiana's love interest is not black. Of course he wouldn't have to be… but why isn't he? One might assume that the perception is that a black guy isn't really worthy of Disney hero status.

Says Disney: "The story takes place in the charming elegance and grandeur of New Orleans' fabled French Quarter during the Jazz Age… Princess Tiana will be a heroine in the great tradition of Disney's rich animated fairy tale legacy, and all other characters and aspects of the story will be treated with the greatest respect and sensitivity."

Of course, much of the information here is based on hearsay. It could very well be a lovely movie without a heavy reliance on stereotypes and a dearth of positive black male characters. But consider this jaded Disney buff's expectations significantly lowered. [Independent]

Comments (28)

No. 1 · frank

Wow Lauren, your a racist!

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 4:24 pm
No. 2 · Orchid

the story line sounds interesting, but like you I don't want to get my hopes up. Though my little sister LOVES Disney and it would be nice for her to see that fairy tales happen to girls and boys like her too.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 4:33 pm
No. 3 · DEAF FEMINIST PUNK!!!!!!!!!!

:(

let's just hope for the best. Knowing Disney, they'd probably be very careful to not piss off people.

anyway, Disney is walking on a very thin egg-shell now because of the whole slutty Miley Cyrus scandal. The last thing they want is more controversy that'll hurt their image.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 4:49 pm
No. 4 · DEAF FEMINIST PUNK!!!!!!!!!!

mmmmm , say, i wonder, how many black people are in top positions at Disney? I'd be curious to know.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 4:53 pm
No. 5 · J

Well, I for one do not know WHO came up with that first cockamamie storyline nonsense because I thought Disney has heard enough about the coloredgirl/white prince thing. That mess is so tired. Aint nobody trying to be rescued by no white prince. And that whole 'voodoo priestess' bit…

And you can keep the 'Black chambermaid' thing. We're tired of that. Disney just sit down.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 4:54 pm
No. 6 · JackJohnson

I would also like to see a story with many different types of ethnicities exhibited via characters. In not in a "the lobster has a Jamaican accent" kind of way. I want my biracial niece to see a character that she might identify with, in form, who is a princess or beautiful fairy (you know, the things little girls are drawn to), and lives a wondrous life. We ALL want the same things, I promise.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 4:56 pm
No. 7 · blackmistressdiva

Next.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 5:13 pm
No. 8 · *M*

Im so excited for this movie..because its hand animated.

All the ridiculous complaints about this
Her name-maddy is short to Madalyn

job- she is black in the 20s…what kind of job to you expect her to have.

white price-whats wrong with interracial..show the kids that black and white can live and love in happily ever after.

is the reason why Disney stayed away from a black princess. People will pick at everything and it can become to much of a risk.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 5:19 pm
No. 9 · Bronze Trinity

I've been boycotting Disney for years because of their racist past and their exclusion of people of colour before the 90s. I think the movie will not be good because they won't put as much effort into it as they do with other films probably. The fact that they are not having a Black prince says a lot to me. They don't want the movie to be "too Black". I thought the same thing about Pocahontas, they couldn't just pick a story that had no White people in it you know? But they have no problems with Arabs in Aladdin or Asians in Mulan though. I wish that there were some African animated films instead of this.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 7:10 pm
No. 10 · Neenee

I was just wondering what was up with this movie this week. I really hope Disney gets it together. Nothings wrong with an interracial couple but I was really hoping this would be positive for Black girls AND boys. We waited long enough for Disney to do this I just wish there was something for my niece and nephew to relate to.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 7:15 pm
No. 11 · mac

Am I the only one that's annoyed by the name Tiana? I liked Maddy so much better.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 8:57 pm
No. 12 · solitaire

ALL of these ideas suck.

How many black princesses lived in NOLA in the 30's? NONE.

How many of them met and married middle eastern and european princes? NONE

I also find it troubling and telling that black people can't fall in love with each other on screen, even in animated form.

Why can't they set it in some historical african kingdom like Timbuktu? I guess they believe the hype of africa being a dark continent with no history or civilization.

Posted: Jul 17, 2008 at 9:41 pm
No. 13 · RhymesWithSilver

RE: the plot- Um, what? Dude, I could brainstorm a better "black princess" story than this in a weekend. And I'm a white chick from the burbs. Even if I couldn't make everyone happy, at least I could avoid being completely stupid.

Wow, Disney. Epic fail in the black princess movie department. Why don't you just let Pixar handle this?

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 1:10 am
No. 14 · ilnazhad

And if the man she ends up living with happily ever after is black, it could kind of give off a message that a white man or a middle-eastern man cannot find a black woman adequate. I think it's fine that her love interest is of a different race. Again, we don't want children to believe that they are limited to being romatically interested to their own race only.

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 1:33 am
No. 15 · Daria at Gorgeous Black Women

Eh. Rumors as you said.

I don't really think it's relevant whether there are top execs at Disney though I'm fairly sure it's whiter and more male than most companies. I'd be more interested in who's writing, directing and producing it.

As for her love interest, I think this is one of those attempts to not make it a "black movie" (=only black people will see it). It seems to be a consistent fear with most movies with a black main character with a love interest that is central to the story. Why Middle Eastern though considering the area? Nothing wrong with that, but that's an odd choice. I would have figured the obvious non-black choice would be Creole and if that's too black, then Spanish. Ah, the issue of balancing so no one in the relationship comes off as superior (the non-black man) or inferior (black woman) based on their race. This is often a problem that will arise when you have interracial couples, especially in kids' movies. Pocahontas, though roughly based on a true story, definitely left a bad taste in my mouth even though I was 11 when that came out after I actually read the story. John Smith was some short, plain dude not some tall, blond hot piece. The guy she didn't want to marry was actually the hot one. Guess that tale is less appealing. Plus they don't end up together.

That Tiana actually looks black is pretty praiseworthy since Pocahontas didn't really look Native American. She was modeled after Christy Turlington and Naomi Campbell!

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 3:38 am
No. 16 · XYZ

Pocahontas was modeled after and voiced by Native American actress Irene Bedard.
http://movies.about.com/od/int.....051005.htm

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 10:19 am
No. 17 · miriam

I don't see why they couldn't just go with an existing folktale or legend. That's what they usually do — cinderella, aladdin, pocahontas, beauty & the beast, the littler mermaid, mulan, etc, etc. sure, they're cleaned up & disney-ified, but it's not like they made those stories up from scratch. at least they have some historical weight and time-tested narrative.

Maybe they could adapt something from Zora Neal Hurston's "Mules and Men"? Or maybe something like "Kiki's Delivery Service" but with a little girl who's an apprentice to Marie Laveau in nola. Would be a lot better than the weak crap these hollywood wonks would make up from scratch.

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 11:17 am
No. 18 · Rachel

Damn. I'm getting "Alzheimered". I would swear i posted on this topic. Anyway.

Funny how Disney's racism didn't strike me in Beauty and the beast, Cinderella, Snow White… and other classics with an "all white cast".

Maybe it's time for African American people to create/produce anime movies for their own kids (any colors or background). And i'm talking about stuff for kiddies… hence not The Boondocks.)

Who can do it better than you!

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 11:53 am
No. 19 · Eric T

Does anyone else think that there should be more black cartoonists?

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 1:02 pm
No. 20 · RhymesWithSilver

While we're on Tiana's appearance, why is she made up like a Jazz-age hooker? That's an awful lot of eyeshadow on those lowered lids of hers.

And she has a slice of lime glued to her head.

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 3:12 pm
No. 21 · RhymesWithSilver

By the way, has anyone watched the Little Mermaid lately? It never occured to me what a disobedient little brat Ariel was when I was six. Or that she was basically running around (swimming around?) in a bra the whole movie. Or that she got married at 16 to a dude she barely knew. A fine role model there…

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 3:18 pm
No. 22 · *M*

You want Little Mermaid as an adult,RhymesWithSilver and her in a bra the whole movies is what you notice.
Not the fact she has to give up her voice to be with a man???

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 4:34 pm
No. 23 · *M*

*watch. Edit button???

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 4:37 pm
No. 24 · blackmistressdiva

"Why can’t they set it in some historical African kingdom like Timbuktu?"

Solitaire - Maybe that wouldn't be profitable from their standpoint?? Disney above ALL else is about $$$.

Posted: Jul 18, 2008 at 4:39 pm
No. 25 · Daria at Gorgeous Black Women

"Pocahontas, according to Edgerton and Merlock, was modeled after three different women. Black British supermodel Naomi Campbell, Caucasian supermodel Christie Turlington, as well as 21 year old Filipino supermodel Dyna Taylor were all inspirations for the animators who were charged with the task of making a "nonpareil"—a woman who is the epitome of what the race has to offer."

Posted: Jul 19, 2008 at 5:35 pm
No. 26 · Me

I actually quite like the fact that she will be paired up with a non-black guy. We all know that the subtext of black women with white men is very different from the opposite. I mean, no one thinks that black men are gross and thats why no one wants them. Everyone wants them of all races. This is hardly a slight to them. If anything it validates the beauty of black women more broadly. Its twisted but true. Additionally, I liked the name Maddy. I also do not have a problem with the voodoo aspect. I think thats a brilliant way to introduce Disney "magic" into a modern film. Of course she is going to be poor. She is black in the 1930s as someone else already said. Cinderella was also poor and no one complained. Anastasia also started off poor. (Well, not started off but by the time we met her in the diagesis of the film she was poor.) So long as there are other well to do black people in the film and so long as they dont all speak in Ebonics all is well. Also, I think the character is well animated in beautiful. All Disney films are a bit sexist/normative. There will always be issues. All I am looking for is a Disney classic whose beauty transcends certain anti feminist/minority messages just as those from my childhood did. All I remember from the little mermaid are some damn good songs.

Posted: Jul 21, 2008 at 10:33 am
No. 27 · Julie

What took Disney so long? Tiana is beautiful, but what's with the helmet on her head? Not actually appealing. This is way overdue. They'd better be in the drawing room working on a Black hero as we speak. I will not have my son only looking up to Lil'Bill. We need production companies that will stick their neck out to properly intergrate AA's into mainstream Hollywood. I don't think it's because AA's don't sell. I think it's because they are afraid they do, thus more competition.

Posted: Jul 21, 2008 at 5:29 pm
No. 28 · STail

Perhaps Disney intends to promote a bi-racial relationship? That's progressive thought, isn't it?

Posted: Jul 22, 2008 at 9:07 pm
Leave a Comment

It's easier to leave comments when you register for an account. It's quick.

Already have an account? Then log in!

Scroll Posts
 


Stereohyped Team

Editor
Lauren Williams

Editor-at-Large
Cord Jefferson

Editorial Director
David Hauslaib

Managing Editor
Andrew Belonsky

Publisher
Jossip Initiatives

Our Network

Jossip The gossip's gossip sheet

Mollygood Splaying celebrities from A- to D-list

Queerty Free of an agenda. Except that gay one

Advertise

Snag our ad info

Roll Blogs

Afrobella
All Hip Hop
The Assimilated Negro
The B Life
Black Agenda Report
Black Male Appreciation
Black Prof
Black Voices
Bossip
Cake & Ice Cream
Clips and Kisses
Clutch Magazine
Concrete Loop
Crunk & Disorderly
Essence
EUR Web
The Fashion Bomb
Giant
Greasy Guide
Hip Candy
HipHopDX
Hip & Pop
Juicy News
King
Miss Info
Mollygood
My Urban Report
Nah Right
Necole Bitchie
Nova Slim
Panache Report
Racialicious
The Rap Up
Rhymes With Snitch
Sandra Rose
Shake Your Beauty
Straight Outta NYC
SOHH
TMZ
Vibe
Wendy Williams
XXL
Young, Black, Fabulous

RSS

 
Copyright 2008 Jossip Initiatives LLC